Sunday, June 8, 2014

Editorial 1.1.1 Rejected From the App Store

Federico Viticci:

Apple rejects Editorial update for a feature that’s been there since August 2013 with version 1.0? Come on, guys.

I mean, I’m pretty sure Apple knows about this app.

Ole Zorn shows the response from App Review:

It would be appropriate to remove this feature from your app or to re-evaluate the concept of your app.

So he removed the ability to download .py files from Dropbox, since that runs afoul of rule 2.7:

Apps that download code in any way or form will be rejected.

So before you get too pleased with how different WWDC 2014 was, remember that Apple is still at war with computer science. Hopefully, they won’t figure out that my notes for WWDC, which include some lines of code, are downloaded from a .txt data file on Dropbox…

Update (2014-06-09): Daniel Jalkut started a conversation about this on Twitter.

Update (2014-06-11): Edge Cases (starting at 41:45) discusses the positive changes at WWDC as being personality driven and a response to competitive threats, rather than a shift in Apple’s beliefs.

Update (2014-06-16): Jesper:

But so much for wanting a theoretical open platform. Apple announced and demonstrated that it’s ready to treat developers better, and it followed it up by announcing and demonstrating that this quest is incompatible by their current methods by rejecting apps that they already have for features that they didn’t just add for breaking rules that they’re not breaking.

3 Comments RSS · Twitter

Zorn also noted on Twitter that .py files were never executable from Dropbox anyhow. What worries me more is will the app get rejected because of the ability to download workflows from the Editorial workflows website. Those *are* executable.

[...] regarded and in the store for years—within 48 hours or it will be removed from sale. As with Editorial, Apple claims that the app violates rule [...]

[…] Executable Code in Educational Apps, Editorial 1.1.1 Rejected From the App Store, Apple Rejecting Apps That Use Rollout, Pythonista in App Store Peril, Briefs Rejected From the App […]

Leave a Comment