Wednesday, September 30, 2026

The App Store Review Process Needs Fixing

Lex Friedman (Mastodon):

Though allegedly focused on benefiting users (through better safety and compliance), App Store review in its current form mostly frustrates the people it claims to protect.

[…]

Those are all scammy apps that got through. Apple’s review capacity isn’t infinite. Every hour a reviewer spends poring over a bug-fix update to an app that’s been in the store for years is an hour not spent catching the fake LastPass app.

[…]

And the review process is fundamentally flawed anyway: It works best with developers who are trying to do the right thing. Plenty of apps pull their content, features, and behavior from servers their developers control. Feature flags, remote configuration, and web views mean an app can behave differently the day after approval than it did the day of vetting. A determined bad actor can get past App Review. An honest developer just waits in a slow, nebulous line.

[…]

At WWDC 2020, the company announced that bug fixes for apps already in the App Store would no longer be held up over guideline violations (except for legal issues); developers could address those problems in a subsequent update instead. That’s a good policy! Based on developer complaints I’ve seen, Apple hasn’t honored that agreement.

He suggests a Trusted Developer Program.

Previously:

Update (2026-11-10): Phillip Shoemaker:

Here’s my prediction. Apple is going to start charging for App Review.

Your first submission will stay free. Volume won’t. You’ll get a set number of updates per app per year, probably four, one a quarter. Want more? Become a VIP and maybe you get twelve. Want a person to look at it today instead of next week? Pay to expedite.

[…]

I can see it because we sketched it years ago. When I ran App Review, we talked about charging developers for reviews more than once.

Update (2026-11-13): Joe Fabisevich:

Apple rejected the latest version of Plinky for “showing subscriptions on my paywall that have not been submitted for review”. The subscriptions in question have been in the app for over two years, and I haven’t made any changes to them since. As always, app review is a clown show.

Previously:

6 Comments RSS · Twitter · Mastodon


This has been suggested for a long time and for the record I agree. It doesn't solve all problems but it creates no new ones and solves a major glaring issue.

I just don't see anything changing here until some major external force causes them to have a "come to jesus" moment, like AI did with Siri. If ChatGPT hadn't come along, Apple would have been perfectly happy to have the same awful Siri for the next many decades, all the while telling us how amazing and capable and trusted it is.

That's where they're at with the App Store. They say the few lines that are technically legally true and ignore all the unpleasant realities. But even worse in this case because those scams make them money.

So really the only way to get them to clean up the App Store is going to be major governments around the world enforcing the same legislation making Apple responsible for copyright infringement and scam losses.

I don't know how that would work but I can't think of anywhere else to hurt Apple the only place the care about, in the wallet.


Apple doesn’t handle well the bureaucracy it already has with App Review, and I worry that any new program (even one designed to fix something) will just be implemented poorly and make things worse somehow.

It’s sad that so many egregious examples of scams are SO EASY to find (e.g. if you just spend 10 minutes looking at Top Grossing), and Apple can’t even do that.  They need to prove they can fix the low-hanging fruit first.


A trusted developer program is just a way to pull the ladder up behind you. And there’s no way to ensure smaller indie devs won’t be priced out or just not allowed to become trusted developers, at least after awhile

It’s also just a bandaid on the real issues of the App Store. The main problem with the App Store is Apple doesn’t have to compete with anyone else because they banned alternative installation options. This means no one can provide a better service and Apple gets to pretend their app store is the best possible solution

This is why we need government mandated sideloading and third party app stores


> This is why we need government mandated sideloading and third party app stores

Fix your communication on this. Apple has reversed and propagandized the term "sideload" to push their rent-seeking behavior.

I don't want a "sideload". Apps aren't just a "sideload"; they're the raison d'etre for owning a device.

I want Free Range Apps. That means install an app with one-tap from /anywhere/, no fake scary messages, no OS fighting me, just click and run like a real computer, because I *own* the device. I don't need a third-party app store (they're fine if they exist) or Nanny State Apple (NSA) stopping me from launching software I want to run on my device.

The App Store is the sideload.

This is why anything iOS-based is a toy and not a personal device, because you cannot run apps freely.

Do not let Apple PR destroy your argument by calling your right to use a device you paid a lot of money for a mere "sideload", like it's some unimportant secondary option. It's very important to Rent Seeking Apple that you think of it that way.

You want Free Range Apps. You want a personal computer. No device needs an App Store.


> He suggests a Trusted Developer Program

Funny. As the real solution is no review at all and let people install the software they want on their hardware without the need to ask Apple permission.


> Here’s my prediction. Apple is going to start charging for App Review.

This would be god-awful and the exact opposite of my feedback to them in surveys for years (where I essentially said, please get rid of all of App Review).

I issue many updates. They are free (Apple does not have a paid upgrade system) so any fee to _provide_ an update would literally lose money. All for something that I do not even want Apple to do, i.e. I want them to just publish my app update and shut up about it.

Leave a Comment