Proton Pass and Proton Authenticator

Is anyone that is serious about password integrity going to use a product like Apple passwords? There's no export feature that I found while briefly testing last year. Compound that with the company's abysmal track record of keeping their platform apps competitive and up-to-date... Setting aside the maxim of not putting all your eggs in one basket. Lastly, why would I trust something as important as passwords to iCloud when Apple repeatedly shows they don't get services? Still no explanation about what a bunch of folks got their Apple accounts reset last year.

So you can sync Proton Authenticator with your Proton account (without using iCloud).
It doesn’t use any “master password”, so it’s only protected with your Proton account login credentials….

I downloaded Proton Authenticator but it doesn’t support importing from Authy. I think the app description on the App Store is for something called Auth, but not Authy. If you try to import into Proton, it’ll list what apps or services it supports and mentions Authy can’t export its data and to ask Authy if they’ll somehow support that in future.

I’ve begun migrating all my Authy codes into Apple Passwords and it works great. But, D Dan mentioned here that there’s been some issue with Apple and resting accounts, so I think I’ll try to use both Apple Paawords and Proton for code generating since Google and a few others allow several authenticator apps to be used, which should hopefully be a good backup measure. That and keeping one-time backup codes.

Briefly looked at this, and there's apparently no self-hosted option. Guess we'll stick to Bitwarden.

>Is anyone that is serious about password integrity going to use a product like Apple passwords? There's no export feature that I found while briefly testing last year.

On macOS, it's File → Export All Passwords to File…, where I would expect it.

On iOS, which still has fewer UI standards than the Mac did in 1984, there's a … menu in the top right, which offers Export Data to Another App.

Authy has no export feature, so it's unreasonable to expect other tools to import from it.

If you already use Proton Pass, then create a new free Proton account for the Authenticator.

I'm pretty sure there is no Notes app forthcoming. Nothing has been announced, and if you have a Proton account, you get a discount on your Standard Notes subscription.

Proton Pass does support import from 1Password, even in 1Password's native format .1pux. I imported my entire 1Password database into it and it brought almost everything succesfully except for files (not sure if those are in the .1pux file or not). So far it feels like a good app on all of the platforms I've run it on, seems very fast, feature-rich and fills in web forms better than 1Password (which surprised me).

@J That’s good to hear about Proton Pass. Proton Authenticator did not offer 1Password for me, and I’m skeptical about the quality on the Mac because there’s no separate Mac app. It’s just the iOS version running on Mac, and they didn’t even bother to tell Apple they verified compatibility for Mac.

"Why include them in the interface when there’s no chance they could work?"

Probably because otherwise, people will keep asking Proton to add support for these apps.