HomeView Reviews
Apple HomeView reviews are out and it looks like a winner, especially for people already using other Apple products. Let’s look at what folks are saying.
I’ve wanted a product like the Apple HomeView for years now. After spending a lot of time with various personal assistant “smart speakers” in my kitchen—some with screens—I’ve never been more certain about the potential of the product category or more disappointed in the reality.
[…]
Given the fact that this product’s tech stack feels like it was created in a blender, it’s remarkable that it holds together as well as it does—but there are still places where the seams show.
[…]
It’s great that you can view iPhone widgets on the HomeView just as you can on the Mac, but it’s a bit frustrating that it will only display the small square widget style. Presumably because of the Apple Watch roots of some of these faces, there’s a surprising lack of digital clocks. In fact, in some face views you can create a face featuring a clock, but if you delete it, you can’t add it back. I admit to being frequently baffled about what I was able to add and customize, and what I wasn’t, when trying to build faces.
[…]
Siri AI isn’t as reliable as it should be, both in general and on the HomeView. Sometimes it just seems to go off in its own world and not respond, or respond accurately. Other times, it works just as advertised.
I spent a week with it at the center of my household, putting those promises to the test with three challenges—including disguising myself as the dad from Apple’s own HomeView commercial.
I plugged it in, set it up, got my wife and son to do what they needed to do to become recognized fellow-family-member users, and then we all collectively have had a week of “Well, now what?”
[…]
The software lacks cohesion and vision and polish.
The HomeView is really making me yearn for a more open version of this product, would be really cool to write custom software for this form factor
Just days after the HomeView’s launch, some owners are reporting problems with Siri, timers, and music playback on Apple’s new smart home hub, based on multiple MacRumors forum threads.
In the longest discussion, which now spans over one hundred posts, several people say their HomeView refuses to set timers or alarms, and instead claims that a software update is required – even though the device reports that it is up to date. In another thread, one poster said an AppleCare senior advisor told them other owners had reported the same problem, and that cold-rebooting their paired iPhone cleared it.
You can long-press to make a text selection but there is literally nothing you can do with the text.
Early HomeView review: it becomes Lead HomePod and “eats” all the Hey Siri commands from the other devices and then does nothing. […] a few hours later it fixed itself and now responds to Siri!
This is an unscientific comparison of response times for the Apple HomeView and the Amazon Echo Studio.
My HomeView hot take review, 24 hours in: it needs to get faster and more reliable at all the things my HomePod mini did before I trust it with anything else.
Siri AI on HomeView is noticeably slower than Classic Siri on my HomePod. It can be a bit frustrating when I’m setting various timers while cooking because it feels stuck in processing my request. My HomePod isn’t far away but they’ve made it so it prefers HomeView even if I go stand next to the HomePod.
I had to turn [Siri AI] off. Half the time it does nothing; and this is for really simple stuff: timers, alarms, adding things to my grocery list. It is abysmal.
Previously: