What’s the order in which you would drop Apple, Amazon, Google, Facebook from your life, if forced to — from first to last.
For me, it would be Facebook, Google, Amazon, and Apple. The first two would be relatively easy. The last two would be hard.
Update (2017-05-06): See also: Aristotle Pagaltzis.
Update (2017-05-12): See also: John Gruber.
Services are a key component of modern Apple. The way the company defines itself, along with the numerous services shoutouts in quarterly earnings calls, prove that.
Despite Apple’s increased focus on services, the common narrative that the company “can’t do services” still hangs around – in online tech circles at least.
But is that narrative still true, or has it grown outdated?
Going through the services he lists:
iCloud Mail: I don’t use this. I can’t imagine ever making a new mail account on a domain I don’t control. I don’t want to be locked into a host. My impression is that iCloud Mail works OK for most people.
Apple Notes: I use OmniFocus and BBEdit/Editorial instead. I don’t like that it locks the notes up in a database.
Reading List: This seems to work fine, but I prefer Instapaper and Pocket.
iCloud Calendar: This works better (with iOS) than Google Calendar. I had some data loss last year, but otherwise it’s been fine. [Update (2017-05-03): A few hours after writing this post, I changed an event’s date to this Sunday, but I got a notification e-mail saying I’d changed it to January 1, 1970 and deleted its title. The “View Event” link in the e-mail doesn’t work, and the event and all its monthly occurrences seem to have been completely deleted. It’s a good thing I had notifications enabled, or I wouldn’t know this had happened. Update (2017-05-28): I’ve also been having problems with notification e-mails being inaccurate. For example, today I changed the title of an event, but the notification e-mail instead says that I deleted the event, and it shows only the new title.]
iCloud Storage: It’s just not very useful to me compared with Dropbox, and I’ve heard horror stories of files disappearing.
Apple Photos: After the way Apple treated Aperture, there’s no way I’ll trust them with my photos again. Lightroom has been a good replacement. I have used Photos from time to time to order prints and books and spent several hours on the phone with Apple Support last fall when it was unable to actually place my order. (It still doesn’t work.) I miss the iPhoto interface and features, as does my wife, who wants to switch to a Web-based print service for our next photo book. I’ve heard syncing horror stories, but not recent ones.
Apple Maps: I continue to find errors nearly every time I use it. Google Maps has more details and is easier to read.
Apple Pay: This seems to work well, and all my main credit cards are supported now. However, it’s not yet widely supported enough that I can stop carrying all the cards.
iTunes and TV: Apple TV has been unreliable for me—i.e. trouble playing videos—the last few years. The iOS TV app is a disaster.
Apple Music: I don’t use it.
Apple News: I don’t use it.
iMessage: We continue to have problems with messages that it says were delivered not arriving, and my mother is unable to send iMessages with attached photos.
Siri: When it works, it’s pretty good (if slow). Unfortunately, around half the time when I’m in the car—with seemingly plenty of cellular bars—it never even processes my utterance. Other apps/services have no trouble using the cell network from my car.
App Store: The iOS App Store app has worked reliably for me, though I’m not very fond of the interface. The Mac App Store app has been buggy.
Update (2017-05-04): Nick Heer:
Despite their presently-good state, however, I get a wary look whenever I recommend many of Apple’s services to someone who asks. A lot of people have been burned before by bad experiences with Maps or iTunes, and are reluctant to trust in more Apple services.
Update (2017-05-06): Nick Heer:
A week later, I received an email from someone in iCloud engineering. She scheduled a call and worked on my case personally. She was able to resolve the bug on my iPhone remotely, but found that a similar bug with Photos on the web wasn’t fixed yet. She filed an internal ticket; nearly a month later, it was fixed, too.
A system like this isn’t scalable. iCloud bugs are such a mysterious black box that a technician at an Apple Store or typical phone support would not be able to assist with resolving them.
Update (2017-05-10): Jordan Merrick:
My experience has been the same as Ryan’s: Apple’s services really are very good and that poor reputation isn’t reflective of what the company achieves today. I’ve since gone all-in and even moved away from some popular third-party alternatives completely.
Update (2017-05-13): Dan Masters:
I used Google Maps for navigation for the first time in ages.
I am flabbergasted by how superior it is to Apple Maps in almost every way[…]
Update (2017-09-04): My mother shoots photos with an iPhone, which uploads them to iCloud Photo Library. Unfortunately, her iPad that syncs with iCloud Photo Library never ends up with a complete set of the photos. It gets about 95% of them, but it’s as if the rest never existed.
Update (2018-10-04): Dominik Wagner:
Messages does have an exceptionally bad day today for me. Total stall around noon where not a single message got out and needed restart. Now late buzzing notifications on many of my devices while messages are already read instantly on laptop. sigh
I’m so glad Apple prioritized iMessage stickers over showing text messages in the right order and syncing messages across devices
